No swift NRL action on shoulder charge

Ben Horne, NZ Newswire July 22, 2012, 8:32 pm

Greg Inglis's sickening collision with Dean Young has fuelled calls for the NRL to ban shoulder charges but no action is likely before next season.

South Sydney star Inglis is expected to face a suspension following the NRL match review committee's meeting on Monday after his shoulder shot appeared to go horribly wrong and he collected Young in the head.

The dazed Dragons forward was taken from the ANZ Stadium field in a neck brace on Saturday night.

It follows similar high profile incidents this season which resulted in Frank Pritchard and Ben Te'o being suspended and prompted the NRL to launch their review of shoulder charges.

Inglis's superstar status and the spectacular footage of the incident will add heat on the NRL to follow the lead of rugby union and ban the high-risk tackle once and for all.

However, Brian Canavan, the NRL's head of the shoulder charge review committee, said no time frame had been set for what was to be a thorough, evidence-based study.

The NRL isn't expecting to hear back from Canavan until the end of the season.

"We'll go to the injury statistics and the medicos and come up with pure fact," said Canavan.

"We'll be using medical people and academics. That's what we'll be arriving at and leave it up to the NRL to make the decisions from there.

"The NRL didn't give us any time-lines as such, they just wanted it to be done thoroughly."

On the research committee with Canavan are NRL doctor Ron Muratore, Dr Hugh Hazzard, Ken Graham and former first grade coach David Waite.

Dr Muratore said the players' association would also be quizzed and research done with a university program which measures forces.

He confirmed there was no time frame but hoped "it won't take very long."

NRL director of football operations Nathan McGuirk, who commissioned the research, said he expected a decision before next season.

In the past two weeks, Young and Parramatta's Fuifui Moimoi have failed to return to the field after being hit high.

That's sparked calls for an 18th emergency player to be introduced from next year to standby for players who are taken out of matches as a result of illegal actions.

McGuirk said the rule change would be looked at but there were a variety of factors to consider.

"It's an issue the competition committee believed had merit last year," McGuirk said.

"We have to understand the consequences of making such a significant change, there's additional costs to the club and the game and salary cap implications."

Newest First
Oldest First
Top Rated
Most Replies


  1. SHELLEY01:02pm Monday 23rd July 2012 NZSTReport Abuse

    A lack of sportsmanship and the shear size of normal forwards means rules also have to grow. And we are talking Aussi's

  2. 09:04am Monday 23rd July 2012 NZSTReport Abuse

    Its a physical game and no player go out there to hurt anyone. As a boxer you try to knock the opposition out as quickly as possible. It is physical sport, and thats why it is so good to watch.

  3. Rod10:36pm Sunday 22nd July 2012 NZSTReport Abuse

    sports policing sucks...check out the deliberate eye shot on the brisbane reds #* by Pietersen....he won't face a judiciary...he won't be's as crooked as hell


League poll

Are the Warriors heading for another disappointing season?

Are the Warriors heading for another disappointing season?


League scoreboard



2015 NRL Premiership Season

9:30pm NZST Sat, 23rd May
6:00pm NZST Sun, 24th May
9:00pm NZST Mon, 25th May
9:45pm NZST Fri, 29th May
5:00pm NZST Sat, 30th May
7:30pm NZST Sat, 30th May
9:30pm NZST Sat, 30th May
4:00pm NZST Sun, 31st May
6:00pm NZST Sun, 31st May

2015 NRL State of Origin

10:00pm NZST Wed, 27th May