Time to do something about the haka?

Sarah Williams, Yahoo! Sport New Zealand October 28, 2011, 12:07 pm

Now that the dust is starting to settle on the Rugby World Cup the inevitable reflection of what was mostly a brilliant tournament is now occurring.

And despite the bad ref calls and the bad-boy behavior of some, it seems the one issue that has got a lot of people going is the haka or as one British journalist put it 'the most tediously touchy of hot potatoes.'

In an article written British broadsheet The Guardian, the journalist Barney Ronay points to the ridiculous incident of France being fined by the IRB for their advancement on the haka before the Rugby World Cup final.

Most, including the All Blacks and the team's manager were disgusted with the $5,000 fine, with many pointing out that France's stand up to the challenge was all part of the excitement.

It is this making a big deal out of nothing, again, that has seen many question the importance of the haka and how people should respond to it.

As Ronay puts it, "The real objection to all this is the sheer tedium of it all.

"On the face of it the haka has everything: theatre, history, spectacle, authenticity. The enduring touchiness about its reception has glazed all of this with a veneer of unwarranted boredom.

"And so the on-field response, and the subsequent rumbles of outrage at the very notion of an on-field response has evolved into a brain-numbingly dull behavioural cycle, a one-upmanship of cultural offence."

It has to be said, in the All Blacks favour, they will perform the haka whether anyone is watching or not, as proved at the Millennium Stadium in November 2006, after they refused to recreate a famous haka from 1905 for the crowd and instead performed it in their shed away from prying eyes.

There can be no doubt that the haka gives the All Blacks a bit of an on-field boost.

What other team in the world has gained the right to make their opponent wait motionless while they perform and when you think about it, it is amazing that it has been allowed to go on for so long.

As Ronay says, getting rid of the haka is not an option.

It is a piece of sporting history that those who witness it in the flesh feel privileged to see, but it is perhaps the way teams are allowed to approach the haka, which in reality is a challenge, that needs to be changed.

Like us on Facebook to get breaking news.
Show:
Newest First
Oldest First
Top Rated
Most Replies

269 Comments

  1. AllBlacks10107:04am Monday 31st October 2011 ESTReport Abuse

    The Allblacks wouldn't be who they are without the haka.Respect that. Only trashy people forget about where they came from,have no respect for who got them there and thats what happens when you have no culture.Typical.

    Reply
  2. Frank06:28am Monday 31st October 2011 ESTReport Abuse

    Choreographed BS, get rid of it.

    Reply
  3. Graham04:37pm Sunday 30th October 2011 ESTReport Abuse

    I love the haka, then I switch off rather than watch the thugby. The haka would have much more force though if the ABs did not let Ali Williams on the side of it.He should be hidden in the back row( or just hidden)

    Reply
  4. Bruce02:22pm Sunday 30th October 2011 ESTReport Abuse

    The Haka is part and parcel of New Zealand life.Who gives a S--t what others think, it`s ours, it`s part of our culture,it unites kiwis.THE HAKA must be preformed all around the world at sporting and all events,just to show we are PROUD to be NEW ZEALANDERS

    Reply
  5. BamBam11:43am Sunday 30th October 2011 ESTReport Abuse

    Haka = global rugby brand = international marketing for the IRB so it's not going anywhere soon. Remember when Wales banned it and then tried to force |NZ to do it as an item BEFORE takin the field? We declined and instead did it in the dressin shed and guess who felt ripped off - no not NZers but the Welsh fans.

    Reply