Why Jesse Ryder is not to blame for the defeat

Hamish Williams, Yahoo! Sport NZ February 23, 2012, 6:11 pm

With the amount of vitriol directed at Jesse Ryder following last night's shocking defeat against South Africa, you would have thought he had done everyone a great personal wrong.

I for one don't believe the he cost us the game. Pure and simple.

He was definitely one of those at fault for the loss, but that doesn't mean we lost just because of him - it's just that I believe Jesse is the easiest target because of his previous history.

And to hear someone like Craig McMillan criticism Ryder so publicly is extremely disappointing.

I will say that he definitely took way too long to go from 49 to 50, and that passage did put the rest of the team under pressure.

But those saying it is all Ryder's fault that we lost are just using him as a scapegoat.

They conveniently ignore the fact that Ryder was top scorer, and his fifty still came at better than a run-a-ball.

They say that he threw his wicket away to a bad shot. But so did Brendon McCullum, Kane Williamson, Nathan McCullum and Doug Bracewell.

But the players who need to put their hands up and take the blame are the four - yes four - batsmen who were at the crease in the final over.

Yes, Ryder going out at that time, to the shot he played was a colossal lapse in judgment, but the target was still an easy one to chase down.

Seven runs off six balls should be a walk in a park, especially with five wickets in hand, on a small ground, and in a Twenty/20 match.

Yet we only scored three runs off the final over, and one of those was a no-ball. In fact we didn't score a single run for four balls in a row.

After Franklin took a single off the first ball, Nathan McCullum left a wide, and was then caught by the keeper. The batsmen didn't cross which left Doug Bracewell to face Marchant de Lange.

The target was still a gettable six off three. All he needed to do was get bat and ball and get Franklin down the other end.

With Franklin backing up and the keeper AB de Villiers a walking wounded, this should have been no problem. Five required off two would have still left NZ slight favourites.

Bracewell is in the side for his bowling (and he is a very good one), but that is all the more reason for him to have left it to the recognised batsman to take them home.

As it was he tried to play hero, went for two filthy heaves that didn't get us a run, but cost him his wicket.

Franklin was finally down the other end, but it was far too little, too late.

A no-ball left us four to win off the last ball. But Tim Southee couldn't do the improbable.

It wasn't Ryder's fault that we lost. It was our lack of composure that killed us off.

Like us on Facebook to get breaking news.
Show:
Newest First
Oldest First
Top Rated
Most Replies

70 Comments

  1. poobearbum06:37am Friday 24th February 2012 ESTReport Abuse

    We lost 2-1 missing 2 of our best players,we did well

    Reply
  2. cameron06:31am Friday 24th February 2012 ESTReport Abuse

    Leave Ryder alone he will be disappointed with his game himself and doesn't need a bunch of couch sitters and over the hill has been cricketers giving their opinions. The team had loads of times they could of won they just didn't. Maybe all these arm chair, I know it all cricketers should go down to their local school and coach a cricket team and put their obvious skills to work . By the way if I remember rightly there is no I in Team.

    Reply
  3. Sue05:53am Friday 24th February 2012 ESTReport Abuse

    I agree with Graeme also and think Ryder is a great cricketer and I just love watch the way he attacks the ball

    Reply
  4. Auckirocky05:30am Friday 24th February 2012 ESTReport Abuse

    Does McMillan need to be reminded of his days not too far ago and that how big a disappointment he was - and maybe was so more often than JR.

    Reply
  5. Kenneth05:20am Friday 24th February 2012 ESTReport Abuse

    He just isn't a team player. Bet there were some tough words in the changing room after

    Reply

Rugby

Results

2013 Brit. & Irish Lions Tour matches (HK & AUS)

2013 Quadrangular Tournament (RSA)

2013 Brit. & Irish Lions Tour matches (HK & AUS)

2013 New Zealand v France

2013 Brit. & Irish Lions Tour matches (HK & AUS)

Schedule

2013 New Zealand v France

7:35pm NZST Sat, 22nd June

2013 British and Irish Lions Tour of Australia

10:00pm NZST Sat, 22nd June

2013 Quadrangular Tournament (RSA)

12:15am NZST Sun, 23rd June
3:15am NZST Sun, 23rd June

2013 Brit. & Irish Lions Tour matches (HK & AUS)

9:30pm NZST Tue, 25th June

2013 Super Rugby Tournament

7:35pm NZST Fri, 28th June

League

Results

2013 English Super League

2013 NRL Premiership Season

2013 NRL Holden Cup

2013 NRL Premiership Season

Schedule

2013 NRL Holden Cup

7:30pm NZST Fri, 21st June

2013 NRL Premiership Season

9:45pm NZST Fri, 21st June

2013 English Super League

7:00am NZST Sat, 22nd June
7:00am NZST Sat, 22nd June

Tennis

Live

2013 Topshelf Open

2013 AEGON International

Schedule

2013 Davis Cup 1st Rnd - KAZ v AUT

2:00am NZDT Sun, 3rd February

2013 Davis Cup World Group I 1st Rnd - TPE v AUS

2:00am NZDT Sun, 3rd February

2013 Fed Cup 1st Rnd - CZE v AUS

2:00am NZDT Sat, 9th February
2:00am NZDT Sun, 10th February

2013 Fed Cup 1st Rnd - ITA v USA

2:00am NZDT Sat, 9th February

2013 Open 13

2:00am NZDT Fri, 22nd February
2:00am NZDT Fri, 22nd February

2013 AEGON International

2:00am NZST Wed, 19th June
2:00am NZST Wed, 19th June
2:00am NZST Wed, 19th June

2013 Topshelf Open

2:00am NZST Wed, 19th June

Cricket

Live

2013 ICC Champions Trophy in England

2nd Innings
Live
South Africa 175 (38.4)
England 3/148 (33.2)
Kennington Oval, London Live Scores

Schedule

2013 ICC Champions Trophy in England

2013 England v New Zealand [T20I]

Football

Results

2014 World Cup Qualifying - CONCACAF

Costa Rica 2 - 0 Panama (FT)

USA 1 - 0 Honduras (FT)

2014 World Cup Qualifying - AFC

Schedule

2013 Confederations Cup (in Brazil)

Brazil v Mexico

20 June 5:00am

Italy v Japan

20 June 8:00am

2013 International Friendlies

Tunisia vs. Morocco

21 June 12:00am

Congo DR vs. Congo

21 June 12:00am

Mali vs. Guinea

21 June 12:00am