Moa "sanction" a wet bus ticket

It could be Taniela Moa's lucky day to go and invest in a Lotto ticket after the leniency handed him by the NZRU.

Moa fronted an NZRU disciplinary hearing in Wellington on Wednesday after his recent misbehaviour at an Auckland rugby club, throwing a bottle which went on to hit a woman at Marist's suburban club rooms.

Under the terms of the NZRU's Collective Employment Agreement, the national body has the power to suspend, fine and even terminate the contracts of those guilty of serious offences.

But on Wednesday the NZRU decided to hand out what appears a highly lenient punishment; a one-week suspension, a $1200 fine, complete an alcohol counselling programme and apologise to the woman who was the unfortunate recipient of his airborne bottle.

On top of that, Moa will partake in community rugby work and help out with teams from his former college.

Before fronting the NZRU misconduct hearing, he also appeared in court on a charge of assault, eventually being granted diversion.

Despite being handed a one-week ban, he will still feature in round 10 of the Rebel Sport Super 14, with the NZRU deeming his sidelining against the Lions last week while the incident was investigated would cover the suspension.

I am staggered at the leniency handed to Moa.

While his supporters will say he has copped it hard, with his reputation being damaged following the well-publicised incident, in reality he has received little more than a whack over the wrist with a wet bus ticket.

At a time when rugby bosses won't allow for the return of rucking as the sight of sprigs taking aim at players trying to kill the ball might not be good for the image of rugby; what sort of a message is Moa's 'punishment' sending?

Flying bottles can often cause worse injuries than a wayward spring.

Incidents of professional players misbehaving in both codes of rugby have become all too common. Thankfully, rugby's rap sheet isn't yet as bad as that seen from the weekly incidents involving league stars across the Tasman.

But if the NZRU was trying to send a message that it wouldn't tolerate incidents such as that of Moa, then I think they have failed badly.

There are two issues here;

One is that an act of bottle throwing is highly serious in its own regard and should have warranted a lengthy suspension.

The other is that the victim of Moa's actions was a woman; that in itself should have brought with it a far sterner response from rugby top-brass.

There is no way Moa should be running out onto Eden Park with his Blues team-mates on Friday night.

Instead he should have been scratched for a prolonged period, even up until the end of the Super 14.

And if you think I am over-reacting, take a second to consider how you would feel if one of your nearest and dearest had been struck with the flying bottle.

What do you think?

Has Moa got off lightly? Or is the incident being blown out of proportion?

YOUR COMMENTS

11 - 15 of 16 Entries
< Previous Page  |
1  |
2  |
3  |
4  |
Next Page >
lynchclan@xtra.co.nz - posted Apr 19 08:49 am
You should check the facts before claiming the moral high ground. This incident has been blown out of proportion. Of course the sentence was appropriate, given the facts. Frankly, I'm surprised a journalist of your experience would pontificate in such a manner without checking the facts. Climb down off your high horse, Mr Reid.
kiwi_blk - posted Apr 19 11:05 am
Jesse Ryder gets suspended for a similar incident as do Ali Williams, and Jimmy Cowan. Seems to me that this is not so much a case of looking after Auckland rugby as Political correctness gone mad. I garuntee that the punishment would have been different if the player had been white - but I guess in Auckland's case that in itself is a rare commodity!!
hexamon@xtra.co.nz - posted Apr 19 06:27 pm
Firstly,where the hell did some of you learn to spell? Taniela Moa is a professional sportsman by career choice. One assumes he was happy to accept all the responsibilities that go with it. You take the money, your in the public eye, your a role model like it or not. If you can't handle your grog, give up the drink or get another job. Don't make excuses for him.
hexamon@xtra.co.nz - posted Apr 19 06:35 pm
smellznice. You are a simpleton. Us kiwis get pissed when our teams lose...Get over it ?.... is that the best you can do. No wonder people look at posts from people like you and think all rugby supporters are knuckle dragging, inarticulate morons with arrested development and maturity issues.
jjjj.co.helsham@xtra.co.nz - posted Apr 20 04:55 pm
Neil, I feel that without all the "facts" we can speculate all we want to about this sad matter. I realise that in your position as a reporter, that you can only report on what you are allowed to, so are we to "speculate" that you have more information then you are "authorised" to share? If so, I agree 100% with you. If not, we need to stop firstly with the "tall poppy syndrome" & secondly using sports people, as role models for society in general. Las
Post a comment
11 - 15 of 16 Entries
< Previous Page  |
1  |
2  |
3  |
4  |
Next Page >

 
To post a new comment, you must Sign in first.

YAHOO!XTRA SPORTS:

ALSO ON YAHOO!XTRA:


Search:
Advertise with us | Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Help
Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! All rights reserved.
Yahoo!Xtra: A Yahoo!7/Telecom New Zealand Company.