If Deans can coach, so too can Hansen

If the NZRU are prepared to help improve Robbie Deans' coaching, then surely they have to give the green-light to Steve Hansen's bid to take charge of the Crusaders.

Hansen confirmed late last week that he had applied to coach the Crusaders in 2009, at the same time as remaining on staff with the All Blacks as forwards coach.

For a start, it is a move which is allowed for under the NZRU's board-enforced protocol.

And it is not as if this would be a first-ever for the All Blacks.

Deans himself invoked the rule during his stint on the All Black coaching panel between late 2001 through to the 2003 World Cup, continuing to coach the Cursaders while working as John Mitchell's assistant at the All Blacks.

That point seems to have been overlooked by sections of the rugby media saying Hansen can't do both roles, scribes who too have shown their colours as confirmed Deans supporters in recent months and weeks.

Not only should Hansen be able to coach the Crusaders if he is the best-qualified candidate for the job because the rules allow him to, he should also get a shot because of the earlier precedent the NZRU set in allowing Deans to continue coaching the Crusaders after signing-on to coach the Wallabies.

Politics surely played a big part in that latter decision.

The NZRU had already alienated elements in some sections of the rugby public, including Cantab fans, by choosing to retain Graham Henry as All Black coach over Deans.

Doing the right thing and abdicating Deans of the Crusaders role would have further soured feelings in the mainland.

The decision to allow Deans to continue on as Crusaders coach gave Deans the perfect leg-up to his new job across the Tasman.

He was afforded a five-month stint coaching under the ELVs, many of which will now be used in the Tri-nations.

That is something which members of the All Black coaching team would surely too have loved to have had.

It also gave him a lengthy stint either coaching or coming up against players he will now be formulating a game-plan to bring down as the Wallabies' head honcho in the Tri-nations.

It appears unlikely that Hansen would have applied for the Crusaders job unless he had a fairly good idea that his bid would be acceptable.


While Deans nominated his assistant Mark Hammett as his preferred replacement, the former All Black hooker has no head coaching experience at representative level.

The other leading contender Todd Blackadder will coach Tasman in the Air New Zealand Cup, but his coaching record to date is rather modest.

So if Hansen is the right man, give him the job.

There's no doubt it will benefit his coaching in the long-term.

And as for comments that it is questioning the pathway of the likes of Hammett, if he ain't ready then it is more prudent to give him a back-room role to continue his development.

What do you think?

Should Hansen be allowed to stay on board with the All Blacks and also coach the Crusaders?

And if Hansen doesn't get the job, who should coach the Crusaders?

YOUR COMMENTS

1 - 5 of 5 Entries
cbonner@xtra.co.nz - posted Jun 30 07:14 pm
I seem to remember that when Deans was associated with the All Blacks and coaching in Canterbury at the same time, there became a preponderance of Canterbury players in the national team, some of them less than deserving it must be said.
dltogether@xtra.co.nz - posted Jun 30 07:24 pm
People may remember back to before Deans did both jobs that Tony Gilbert was not
allowed the same pleasure when he was removed from coaching the Highlanders whilst
"helping" with the AB's. Surely anyone else must be better than Hansen, given that the
"Holy Trio"stood (& should have fallen) by the same sword for the world cup. If they cant
honor their word (judge us on WC!!) where can they be trusted??
haydenjshaw - posted Jun 30 08:15 pm
Agree totally with you Neil. Of course he should be able to do both. Deans was allowed to do it so should Hansen. Some people in the media need to pull their heads out of Dean's ar-e.
fialemaa - posted Jun 30 09:42 pm
Gilbert was unfortunate that the Chairman and CEO of the NZRU were not from the same province as him.
Hansen is infinitely more qualified than Hammet and Blackadder. He should be the Crusaders coach.
kiwi_blk - posted Jul 1 12:11 pm
I agree in princile to Hansen being allowed the Crusaders job. Bear in mind that he is only an assistant on the All Blacks staff, and that he must do as the Headmaster decrees. Also, it does well to remember that Hansen has done time with the Crusaders, but not as head coach - he knows the culture there and would easily fit in, and i think would be acceptable to the majority of us cantabs. It could go a long way towards bringing back some of the supporters here - yeah - I think it would be ok .
Post a comment
1 - 5 of 5 Entries

 
To post a new comment, you must Sign in first.

YAHOO!XTRA SPORTS:

ALSO ON YAHOO!XTRA:


Search:
Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Help
Copyright © 2008 Yahoo! All rights reserved.
Yahoo!Xtra: A Yahoo!7/Telecom New Zealand Company.