Rokocoko pick is insulting our intelligence

I've never had the problems with Graham Henry and the All Blacks' brains trust that some in the media (and to be fair some ordinary fans around New Zealand) have had.

Don't get me wrong - I'm not someone who's been blindly banging the drum for Ted but I've never been one to criticise him for the sake of criticism.

And I thought the decision to retain him for the World Cup 2011 campaign showed a rare maturity for a country which usually dumps the coaches after World Cup failure.

It didn't work in the past so why not try something new?

Anyway, I may be forced to eat my words of encouragement after the announcement of the All Blacks team to play Australia today.

When I announced to the office Joe Rokocoko had retained his place in the team it's fair to say the rugby fans were stunned.

But their disbelief was made worse by the fact that two youngsters in Isaac Ross and Owen Franks have been given the bum's rush.

Of course I'm not watching Rokocoko in training every day and seeing the effort he's putting in - but even if that is true he's not transferring it to the paddock on a Saturday night.

Two good games in the Air New Zealand Cup this season is all we've got to show for Joe's rugby efforts this season - and as Steve Hansen was at pains to point out at the weekend, just because someone plays well at the third level of rugby doesn't mean they're ready to play internationally.

But I feel incredibly sorry for Franks and Ross more than anything else.

I've had the pleasure of interviewing both these kids and it's been an enjoyable experience. Not bounded by years of media training they're brutally honest with what they say and occasionally may say more than they should.

And their form hasn't exactly been the worst.  In fact Ross - in both mine and many of the people I've spoken too - has been one of the standouts of the poor international season so far.

But what message are the coaches sending to Franks and Ross and every other young player who aspires to play in the black jersey?

The only message I'm seeing is "If you're in with us you can fail to play to the expected standard and still retain your spot."


How many times have we been told that players are picked on form? They can't possibly keep using that argument while Rokocoko keeps his place in the team because none of us are that stupid.

And Neemia Tialata hasn't exactly been setting the world on fire in the Air New Zealand Cup, has he?

Do you get the feeling I'm angry about this? Because I am. These kids are the future of New Zealand rugby and they're being ditched in order to win a game which in the grand scheme of things means nothing.

This was THE game to persist with Franks and Ross and to bring other youngsters, like Hosea Gear Aled de Malmanche and Wyatt Crockett, into the team.


Who cares if we finish last in the Tri-nations this year. We're not champions and we've already retained the Bledisloe Cup therefore it doesn't make any difference.

But this was a chance to build for the future, to blood the youngsters who will be needed if we want to win the World Cup in 2011.

And instead we cast them aside in the name of trying to secure a face-saving win.

So what do you think? Can you tell me why Joe Rokocoko has been picked again? Do you think Isaac Ross and Owen Franks should have kept their spots? And what other changes would you have made?

I appreciate all your comments.

YOUR COMMENTS

1 - 5 of 220 Entries
< Previous Page  |
1  |
2  |
3  |
4  |
5  |
6  |
7  |
8  |
9  |
10  |
11  |
12  |
13  |
14  |
15  |
16  |
17  |
18  |
19  |
20  |
21  |
22  |
23  |
24  |
25  |
26  |
27  |
28  |
29  |
30  |
31  |
32  |
33  |
34  |
35  |
36  |
37  |
38  |
39  |
40  |
41  |
42  |
43  |
44  |
Next Page >
james_blewman - posted Sep 16 02:05 pm
Absolutely spot on with your assessment. I also feel angry and can't understand their logic.
nz_browser - posted Sep 16 02:11 pm
I would love to be able to answer your questions but unfortunately I feel exactly the same way. Othere selections in the past were arguable (for and against). These ones no one can argue for. Simply bad calls
tup_pence@xtra.co.nz - posted Sep 16 02:53 pm
It is the culture of this present AB squad that has got to change to bring about a long term positive change.Roko being selected again is just stupid.To dump Ross is even worse.A young player given all the responsibility of line out calls and then he is cast off like a dirty shirt.It is not his fault that the lineout is crap.What guidance is Hansen giving?I suppose that if the ABs win against Aussie(albeit by Carter penalties)we will be told that we have turned the corner and are on the way up.
markkaren@xtra.co.nz - posted Sep 16 02:58 pm
I agree with your comments, and if we think that Toeava is going to solve all our problems, just because for the first time he didn't drop the ball, then heaven help us all. Our coaching staff/selectors are a group of buffoons. I live in the North Island and even I can see that Christchurch players like Ross and Franks simply do not fit Henry's world of Auckland for ever...how else can he continue to think that Toeava and Rokocoko are worthy our OUR black jersey.
fitzp56@xtra.co.nz - posted Sep 16 03:30 pm
Joe Rokocoko was picked ahead of the impressively in-form Doug Howlett in the infamous quarter final of the last world cup... and one can't help but think that whatever it is that these coaches saw in Joe then is still the world's greatest mystery. Nothing against the guy personally, but how long is it going to be before the selectors waken up and learn from their mistakes?
Post a comment
1 - 5 of 220 Entries
< Previous Page  |
1  |
2  |
3  |
4  |
5  |
6  |
7  |
8  |
9  |
10  |
11  |
12  |
13  |
14  |
15  |
16  |
17  |
18  |
19  |
20  |
21  |
22  |
23  |
24  |
25  |
26  |
27  |
28  |
29  |
30  |
31  |
32  |
33  |
34  |
35  |
36  |
37  |
38  |
39  |
40  |
41  |
42  |
43  |
44  |
Next Page >

 
To post a new comment, you must Sign in first.

YAHOO!XTRA SPORTS:

ALSO ON YAHOO!XTRA:


Search:
Advertise with us | Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Help
Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! All rights reserved.
Yahoo!Xtra: A Yahoo!7/Telecom New Zealand Company.