Talk about a tough ride

The vehement reaction to the Aussies' 2 nil loss to India and Ricky Ponting's captaincy has once again emphasized to me what a cushy ride our Black Caps enjoy.

I cannot think of a more demanding and accountable job in sport than that of captain of the Australian cricket side.

Far more than is the case here, an Aussie captain appears to take most of the responsibility for his team's fortunes. 

Expectation is immense. Accountability is paramount. Success is demanded. Failure can be fatal. All of which was starkly demonstrated during the Baggy Greens' tour of and eventual demise in India.

There is no tougher task in international cricket than winning on the sub-continent. Alien conditions, illness and on this occasion, as good as Indian squad as ever was always going to make for one very demanding foray.

Add to that the fact that for most of the series, the Aussies spinning armory was ordinary at best, underlining what a colossus Shane Warne has been in Australia's relentless successes while he spun his magic.

Plus the recent retirements of the heavyweights such as Glenn McGrath, Adam Gilchrist and Justin Langer is also still being felt.

This all translated into the likelihood of the Aussies winning the test series in India nigh on impossible, drawing it a possibility and losing the most likely outcome.

And lose they did.

A result mostly in keeping with the Indians' marked supremacy throughout the series and a second test defeat enhanced by Ponting's odd endeavors to rectify an incriminating slow over rate.

This was Ponting's first series loss since the Poms dealt to his team in 2005.

The bald facts spearheading the career of Ricky Ponting are these:

He is Australia's most successful test captain ever.

His zeal for winning is synonymous with his ruthless sense of pride and patriotism.

On a personal note, Ponting is one of only seven players who have amassed over 10,000 runs.

He has the best average of the top twenty test run scorers of all time and only Sachin Tendulkar is pipping him for the most test centuries ever posted.

But if like me, you thought this wondrous overall record would insulate Ponting from the stinging criticism showered upon him after losing in Nagpur, how wrong we were.

As was the case in the bitter series against India in Australia earlier this year (and probably more deserving), many eminent ex-players and coaches have been calling Ponting's authority and judgment into question.

To his relief, other notables such as Steve Waugh and Aussie cricket chief, James Sutherland have been stoic in their defense of the little Tasmanian master.

Regardless of the relative fairness of the opposing opinions, once again, accountability has been at the forefront of the debate. And that in itself is a particularly healthy exercise I believe.

As mentioned, compare that to the truly pathetic lack of genuine accountability at national level here in Godzone.

Compare that to the destructive nonsense of allowing John Bracewell to see out the whole of his contract and not leaving until April 2009, a year or so after he announced he wanted to vacate the role.

How sad! How soft! How silly!

First, Martin Snedden and now Justin Vaughan have put mateship ahead of the good of the Black Caps and their long-suffering fans while Bracewell has kept New Zealand at a dismal seventh out of nine in the ICC test rankings for most of his time at the helm.

The pursuit of mediocrity and non-accountability is alive and well at New Zealand Cricket's headquarters.
 
Your thoughts please.

PS. I always knew Keven Mealamu was a Samoan. A typing mistake let me down. Apologies for the glitch and thanks to my biggest fans for pointing it out!

YOUR COMMENTS

1 - 5 of 14 Entries
< Previous Page  |
1  |
2  |
3  |
Next Page >
mattyngnz - posted Nov 14 02:37 pm
At least Cricket Australia hasn't spent $130k on an enquiry on why they lost the test series. The problem with Braces is that no one really wants the Black Caps job, so that's why they haven't fired him already...
bgately22 - posted Nov 14 07:16 pm
You can't compare the black caps with the Aussie cricket team. try comparing them to the All Blacks. Both won their respective World Cups in 1987. Both have lost a heap of their experienced players recently but are still expected to win every game. Both have been red-hot favourites for the last 3 world cups. BUT the Aussies have won 3 IN A ROW.
conrad_fitzgerald - posted Nov 16 09:20 pm
At first I thought the comparison to the ABs was strange, but then I realised; How vilified would McCaw and Henry be if they lose the next 2 tests and didn't get the Grand Slam? What if they lose to Munster?The pressure on the top teams, in any sport, to stay on top is huge. As the old saying goes,"the bigger they are, the harder they fall". Thats what makes Ponting a great captain, God help whoever they play over the next few years as they will cop a beating.
haydenjshaw - posted Nov 17 11:48 am
I cant believe the stuff coming out of Australia either about Ponting. I have no problem with Bracewell staying on as coach. If Vettori said he wanted to retire after the next world cup should be drop him now? Our test record under Braces is rubbish but we have a pretty good one day record. Our players simply are not that good at the longer version of the game. I dont believe that is Bracewell's fault. It starts well before him
basilbrown@rocketmail.com - posted Nov 17 01:59 pm
Ask Astle, Cairns and McMillan whether Bracewell should still be there. A resounding no will be your answer. Yer can't compare Vettori retiring with Bracewell. One has just begun and is leading by example....the other is a proven failure as coach in the most important part of the game. I agree with MITS that we have no real accountability in the game here cos wishy-washy views like yours hjshaw dominate.
Post a comment
1 - 5 of 14 Entries
< Previous Page  |
1  |
2  |
3  |
Next Page >

 
To post a new comment, you must Sign in first.

YAHOO!XTRA SPORTS:

ALSO ON YAHOO!XTRA:


Search:
Advertise with us | Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Help
Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! All rights reserved.
Yahoo!Xtra: A Yahoo!7/Telecom New Zealand Company.